Wednesday, October 7, 2015

No Room for Debate

Elizabeth Catlett, Invisble Man
Don’t ask me how I became the head of the debate team.  It’s laughable that my name and the word “coach” would ever exist in the same sentence.  Competitions make me anxious because I feel too deeply for the losers.  But, I guess these are the breaks when you are a new employee.  You have to take the assignments that others have been wise enough to avoid.

Every Wednesday I meet with a group of around twenty 6th-8th graders for an hour.  During that time the students conduct research on both sides of a topic determined by the debate league that we belong to.  They have to be knowledgeable about both the proposition and opposition positions because they are not told what side of the issue they will be asked to argue until the day of the debate.  On Saturdays they compete against other private and charter school students. 

When I opened up my email earlier in the week, I read that one of the three topics was “Ban the public displays of Confederate symbols.”  Today, as I copied the statement onto the whiteboard in purple Expo marker, I shook my head at the insensitivity of the topic.  Dylan Roof killed nine Americans in a church in June, and here we are in October asking MIDDLE SCHOOL students research arguments justifying the display of Confederate symbols.  People can be so clueless at times.

I didn’t really get angry until I sat down with the one black girl on the team (also the only black person in the 8th grade).  She was very clear about the fact that she didn’t like the topic, and she asked me to send a letter to the organizers in protest.  I don’t need to imagine how uncomfortable she felt having to research a topic that made her race especially salient.  Luckily, her teammates were pretty disgusted with the topic as well- either that or they were scared of her :)

As we sat there in front of our laptops, I thought about all of the crazy ways that this scenario could play out on the day of the debate.  Imagine one of the all black charter school teams (who are sometimes mocked and always underestimated) standing up defending the display of the Confederate flag, while the all white the private school team makes the opposite argument.  Who would I root for in that contest??

Or what if the debate organizers decided that the charter school team should argue against the display of the Confederate symbols and the black kids ended up losing the debate?  How self-esteem shattering would that be?  

Yes, it is important for children to learn about all sides of an issue and understand the perspectives of the parties involved.  However, asking a twelve year old black child to stand in front of a room of adults and her peers and justify the display of the Confederate flag four months after a racially motivated mass shooting is a slap in the face.

In America, we would never ask Jewish children to defend the use of Nazi symbols in a debate.  I would hope that we would know better than to ask Native American students to argue in favor of the Redskins team name and logo.  Why then, would we ask children who are the descendants of those who survived slavery to stand up in front of an audience and defend the use of symbols glorifying it?  What kind of hotmessmindfuckery is that?   Think about the dissonance that that would cause a black child.

And what of the white students?  Some were able to approach the activity as a purely intellectual exercise, but a few of the older students were savvy enough to understand that they were copying language coded with racism into their carefully organized GoogleDocs.  I wondered what assumptions would be made about them (fairly or unfairly) if they were a little too convincing in their arguments in the opposition on the day of the debate.  If they are chosen to defend the display of Confederate symbols, do they lose on purpose in order to avoid being perceived as a  racist? 

The most aggravating part of this is the fact that this topic was chosen by people who probably did not consider any of these issues.  (Did they assume that all of the debaters would be white kids with no emotional investment one way or the other?)  

Because of the ignorance of the organizers, I am put in the position of the black person who has to educate grown people about race and risk being called "oversensitive".  Or even worse, I am asked to turn moments of black discomfort into a "teachable moments" for white people.  YUCK.


In Ralph Ellison’s novel, Invisible Man, the vet tells the narrator to “play the game, but don’t believe in it.”  That is my usual strategy when I'm on Central Park West.  Unfortunately, this is one game that I can not play.

Monday, October 5, 2015

The Fall Five

Fall is here.  Gone are the days of waking up when my body feels like it, throwing on my favorite pair of jean shorts, and exploring the city with Chloe.  These days I'm up at 6am and so exhausted that I can barely speak by 2:55pm.  Teaching is a delicate balance of pushing children past where they feel comfortable, while simultaneously keeping them from hating you.  It's harder than it looks! 


Below is a list of the things that are currently helping to ease my transition back into work mode.

1. Lianne La Havas, Blood.  I loved Lianne La Havas's first album, Is Your Love Big Enough? and her second album of soul/folk songs doesn't disappoint.  Her work is a combination of vulnerability and  righteous indignation, fueled by her strident voice and her guitar.  My favorite songs are "What You Don't Do," and "Grow."  Prince is a fan, so you don't have to take my word for it.


Listen to La Havas cover Jill Scott's "He Loves Me."


2.  Perfect Match Nail Color in "Mi Amor." A few years ago manicures were an occasional indulgence for me, but now I feel naked without one.  Gel manicures are the best because I don't have to worry about my nails chipping when I am digging in my bag or smudging while I am talking out Chloe's braids.  Having freshly painted, shiny nails helps me feel put together, and I love this not-too-dark/not-too-light nude color for fall.  The great thing about Perfect Match is that they have corresponding non-gel colors for my pedicures.

3. Nars Audacious Lipstick in "Leslie," and Sephora MicroSmooth Baked Blush in "Rose Emotion.  If I don't have lipstick on when I come to work my students are the first to let me know that all is not right with the world.  I am giving my red lipstick a break for fall and going back to the rich browns that I wore in high-school and college.  "Leslie," billed as a "cherrywood" color is both moisturizing and long lasting.


I discovered this blush while shopping in Sephora with Alexis. It is intensely pigmented and gives me more color than the blush that I usually wear.   I love that the Sephora collection products are so affordable because after spending $32 dollars on Nars Lipstick, my cosmetics budget is basically finished :/
4. The Sugar Hill Children's Museum of Art and Storytelling.  Chloe and I stopped into this museum on Sunday and  I was pleasantly surprised by how nice it is.  Designed for children ages 3-8, the museum is part of The Sugar Hill Project which seeks to meld affordable housing with cultural education as a means of encouraging neighborhood revitalization.  Families can engage workshops in the spacious art studio and visit works by Elizabeth Catlett and Romare Bearden on loan from The Studio Museum in Harlem.  Furthermore, the website says that the space will be available for birthday parties facilitated by museum educators.  This is a great place to bring restless kids to create art and make new friends on the weekends; I wish that it was around years ago when Chloe was younger.

5. The Heart Goes Last, by Margret Atwood.  Imagine a world characterized by violence and unemployment where people live in their cars and are afraid to walk through the park.  In the dystopian world of Margaret Atwood's The Heart Goes Last, The Positron Project aims to be the solution to these problems.   The project offers people the opportunity to live in a flourishing suburb six months out of the year, if they agree to live in prison the other six months.  A biting commentary on the prison industrial complex  and corporate culture, The Heart Goes Last  illustrates Atwood's point in The Handmaid's Tale that "[people] can get used to anything, as long as there are a few compensations."   



Sunday, September 20, 2015

Caitlyn Jenner is No Hero

Something about Caitlyn Jenner has always rubbed me the wrong way.  I kept my opinions to myself because I did not want anyone to be able to use my thoughts to justify their own transphobia or transantagonism.  However, the media's dogged attempts to cast Caitlyn as a hero and a symbol of American progressive attitudes about gender has really gotten on my last nerve.  As I gingerly broached the subjects with friends (and one of my students) I began to realize that I was not the only one giving Caitlyn Marie Jenner the side-eye.

My misgivings about Caitlyn began when she was still Bruce, starring in a series of episodes at the end of end of Keeping Up With the Kardashians called "About Bruce."   In these shows Bruce talked about his desire to live authentically, although he was purposely vague about what that meant.   What was  more disturbing were the interviews with his children.  Although they tried to put a positive spin on the changes affecting their family, much of what they discussed seemed deeply traumatic:  Accidentally seeing one's step-father dressed as a woman and having to keep that secret for years, finding make-up and assuming that it meant that your father was having an affair, and suspecting that your father figure has swiped clothing and make-up from you are all things that would send anyone to therapy.

It is one thing to live a lie, but it is another thing entirely to force your children to, not only to live a lie as well, but to collude in spreading this lie to the world in the form of a "reality show."  When we consider the family history of the Kardashians is it any surprise that all of the Kardashian sisters (minus Kourtney) seek out relationships with black men, who are considered the paragon of masculine sexuality.  
Posted on Instagram by Khloe
When I Am Cait premiered this summer I, like most people, tuned in to see what Cait was going to look like.  How would she define her personal style?  Would she wear a wig?   Does facial feminization surgery really work?   However, watching the show I was reminded of Toni Morrison's statement in The Bluest Eye that physical beauty is "one of the most destructive ideas in the history of human thought" because it "begins with envy, thrives in insecurity, and ends in disillusion."  Caitlyn seemed to delight in the fact that she could now participate in the beauty rituals that she had jealously watched her wife and daughters engage in.  She seemed giddy that she owned the same dress as her ex-wife even suggesting they they have a "who wore it best" competition (shady).  
I want to wear this DVF dress on my birthday!
Despite all of the money she had invested in plastic surgery, clothing, hair, and make-up Jenner still seemed unsatisfied with her appearance as a woman as demonstrated by her preoccupation with a voice that she deemed as too masculine.  It reminded me of the end of The Bluest Eye when Pecola finally got her dreamt for blue eyes, but immediately became overwrought with the idea that they were not blue enough.
Everything connects back to The Bluest Eye :)
Notably, the producers of I Am Cait tried to use the show as a platform to discuss the struggles of non-celebrity members of the transgender community.  Unfortunately, Caitlyn didn't seem quite down for the cause.  In fact, she demonstrated more angst over the tone of her voice than over the rate of suicide and sex work in the transgender community.  In a support group meeting, when someone mentioned relying on state assistance to survive, Caitlyn repeated the racist/classist Republican mantra of welfare making people not want to work.   Jenner asked, "don’t, a lot of times, they can make more not working with social programs than they actually can with an entry-level job?”  He went on to say,  “you don’t want people to get totally dependent on it.  That’s when they get in trouble. ‘Why should I work? I got a few bucks, I got my room paid for.’”  Jenner seemed not to recognize that all members of the transgender community do not make a living off their participation in a show about professional pretty people, nor do they  get paid to pose on the cover of Vanity Fair in their underwear.*  

Caitlyn Jenner's lack of sensitivity was again on display when asked by Ellen Degeneres about his stance on gay marriage.  Speaking of his prior beliefs he said,  “I’m a traditionalist;  I’m older than most people in the audience. I kind of like tradition, and it’s always been a man and a woman. I’m thinking, ‘I don’t quite get it.’”  Say what??????  

Although, Jenner stated that he now accepts that everyone has the right the be happy and that gay marriage is now the "law of the land" even Ellen wasn't quite buying it.  Of course, one's gender shouldn't necessarily determine one's political beliefs, but one's membership in a persecuted minority group should at least make them more sensitive to the struggles of others.  





*“I would like to see a nice transgender person who wore jeans and a sweatshirt,” Toni Morrison on Caitlyn Jenner’s Vanity Fair cover



Monday, September 14, 2015

Dispatches From the Frontline of Online Dating

The other day I walked into 7th grade orientation and observed a 12 year old swiping away on Tinder.   Aside from the fact that Tinder is obviously not on the list of approved educational apps, this was concerning because a boy who grows up believing that women are disposable beings to be judged solely on their looks will turn into a man with the same limited vision.  

For adults, online dating can be great; I know several couples who met on dating websites and it beats being almost 40 in the club (do people still go to clubs?)   Unfortunately, there is also a lot of foolishness occurs on the internet.  Below are a few of my observations:

There are a lot of hurt men out there:  Those who believe that men are “the stronger sex” apparently have never met anyone online.  One dude that I went of two dates with would send me short stories through text about how he had been cheated on and “didn’t feel like a man.”  Huh? If you don't feel like a man what are you doing on a date?   And more than that, what woman hasn't been cheated on?  As women we can be wounded in the most intimate ways, but we bounce back and still love like we’ve never been hurt. In short, all 'bag ladies' aren't women.


Beware of Match.com Missionaries:  The last two men that I have met online have been born-again Christians hiding major issues behind The Bible.  One, let’s call him Michael, preached to me about Abraham and Isaac over curried chicken at Cedric, and then revealed to me that he had a previously unmentioned ex-girlfriend who was claiming to be pregnant.  Unless the woman's name was Mary, I assume that she was impregnated by this scripture quoting gentleman.  He apparently saw no contradiction.

Another man sent me a screen shot of the Bible passage that he was reading but neglected to notice that he was also sending me his buddy list with ten other women he was currently having conversations with.  He insisted that in heaven there would be no relationships since we would all be married to Jesus, and he was just doing that here on earth by cultivating a collection of "friends."  When I told him that women were paying $50.00 a month to find a man, not a friend,  his joking response was "I'm trying to give them one," (referring to Jesus).  Since when is The Bible the Player's Handbook?

Black Jesus always needs a flock
Dating is a lost art:  I didn’t understand the importance of dates until I was in my 30’s (Thanks,  John Marshall).  Spending all day on the phone with someone creates a false sense of intimacy, and just "meeting up" at someone's house is for childless women in their 20's.  Whether a man is willing to put in the time, effort, and expense planning something is a good indication of whether or not he is serious about you.  On man suggested that I cook for him and he could eat while we walked around the block getting to know each other.  Needless to say, I never spoke to him again.

Going on a date doesn't ensure that you will end up together, but it does ensure that if you don't become a couple, you will still have some fun memories.  And sorry, Starbucks doesn’t count.   


For some, the honeymoon never ends:  As fun as dating is, if you meet online you have to accept that you can go on a perfect date with someone and never see them again.  The Internet can breed chronically unsatisfied people who are constantly on the lookout for someone better.  There are also some men who live for the honeymoon stage, just not with the same person.  The honeymoon stage is great! Why move past it if you never have to? A shiny new person is only a click away.

The closet still exists:  I’m just going to leave that there . . .Well, actually, I'm not.  I had a revelation the other day while watching the Love and Hip Hop Atlanta Reunion (it happens).  Everyone on stage was trying to "out" Nikko because he is in his 40's without kids.  Margauex made a good point (which was lost on the audience) by saying that judging (and shaming) someone's sexuality based on surface characteristics is what keeps black men on the DL and in the closet.  HOWEVER, if a man asks you "why everyone thinks that he's the cute bi-sexual guy" without prompting, you may be dealing with a "cute bi-sexual guy."  As with everything, it's important to trust your intuition.

And continue to believe in love . . .